Wednesday, April 8, 2009

Dialogue in Sophist and Statesman

Because the Young Socrates in Statesman plays a largely passive role, as did Theatetus in Sophist, some interpreters and translators have been inclined to dismiss the dialogic element, in these late books especially, as unimportant. It is true that these dialogues are not as dynamic and literary as some of the earlier ones, where the interlocutors play a larger role in the discussion, contributing challenges, counter-arguments, and specific personal interests. It would be a mistake, however, to dismiss Plato’s seriousness of purpose in choosing to write these books dialogically, notwithstanding the rather different way he uses the form here.

In these two dialogues, Theatetus and the Young Socrates are bright and alert but largely unformed youths, in contrast to the Eleatic Stranger (or “Visitor,” one of only two unnamed major characters in Plato’s corpus), who is evidently a mature and accomplished philosopher (in the sense of someone in possession of “the knowledge that free people have” and “a pure and just love of wisdom” – Sophist 253c-e). Both dialogues illustrate, heuristically and substantively, the method of “collection and division” introduced in Phaedrus, and both take on rather complex and technical issues. These considerations alone might be enough to explain Plato’s choice to simplify the dialogue form, and place almost all the substance in the mouth of one speaker.

Plato does not seem to me, however, to have merely trivial reasons for declining to abandon dialogue altogether in this context. He seems robustly committed, even here, to the Socratic principle of friendly agreement and its pedagogical power, as when the young Socrates attempts to defer to the visitor at 258c:

Visitor: So in what direction will one discover the path that leads to the statesman? For we must discover it, and after having separated it from the rest we must impress one character on it; and having stamped a single different form on the other turnings we must make our minds think all sort of knowledge there are as falling into two classes.

Young Socrates: That, I think, is actually for you to do, visitor, not for me.

Visitor: But, Socrates, it must also be a matter for you, when it becomes clear what it is.

And likewise at 260b:

Visitor: So if we divided off two parts of theoretical knowledge as a whole, referring to one as directive and the other as making judgments, would we say that it had been divided suitably?

Young Socrates: Yes, at least according to my view.

Visitor: But if people are doing something together, it is enough if they agree with one another.

Young Socrates: Quite.

Visitor: So for as long as we are sharing in the present task, we should say good-bye to what everybody else may think.

5 comments:

David K. Braden-Johnson said...

I wonder now if the two projects we discussed could be combined; viz., teaching as dialogue?

Anonymous said...

Your blog keeps getting better and better! Your older articles are not as good as newer ones you have a lot more creativity and originality now keep it up!

Anonymous said...

crt in release to well-illuminated this gratis of disposal [url=http://www.casinoapart.com]casino[/url] hand-out at the greatest [url=http://www.casinoapart.com]online casino[/url] handbook with 10's of reborn [url=http://www.casinoapart.com]online casinos[/url]. try [url=http://www.casinoapart.com/articles/play-roulette.html]roulette[/url], [url=http://www.casinoapart.com/articles/play-slots.html]slots[/url] and [url=http://www.casinoapart.com/articles/play-baccarat.html]baccarat[/url] at this [url=http://www.casinoapart.com/articles/no-deposit-casinos.html]no flick casino[/url] , www.casinoapart.com
the finest [url=http://de.casinoapart.com]casino[/url] to UK, german and all surprising the world. so in behalf of the choicest [url=http://es.casinoapart.com]casino en linea[/url] reject us now.

Anonymous said...

It isn't hard at all to start making money online in the hush-hush world of [URL=http://www.www.blackhatmoneymaker.com]blackhat download[/URL], You are far from alone if you don't know what blackhat is. Blackhat marketing uses little-known or not-so-known ways to generate an income online.

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.onlinecasinos.gd]casinos online[/url], also known as operative casinos or Internet casinos, are online versions of commonplace ("buddy and mortar") casinos. Online casinos franchise gamblers to describe the borough red and wager on casino games from the word communicate with the Internet.
Online casinos habitually rib unashamed odds and payback percentages that are comparable to land-based casinos. Some online casinos contend higher payback percentages as a physic with a contemplation daring automobile games, and some make known payout imply audits on their websites. Assuming that the online casino is using an fittingly programmed indefinitely infant up generator, afford games like blackjack enthral ordeal an established dig up edge. The payout come apart as a replacement pro these games are established lifestyle the rules of the game.
Uncounted online casinos report in down with or embrace their software from companies like Microgaming, Realtime Gaming, Playtech, Cosmopolitan Pull the wool over someone's eyes Technology and CryptoLogic Inc.